fbpx
Saturday, October 6th, 2012

PINK RIBBONS INC

It’s questionable if filmmaker Lea Pool’s investigation into the breast cancer movement suffers from the lack of an indignant Michael Moore type expose but it does raise some very pertinent issues about this unwieldy juggernaut of a crusade that some think may now be out of control. Pool does however overload us somewhat with a torrent of images of a multitude of money raising walks mixed with interviews of survivors plus with the heads of the two major fundraising foundations interspersed, and a few researchers/experts and the points she is trying to make do occasionally get muddled along the way.

Like it or not, this is a big business. The major player ‘Susan G Korman For The Cure’ is reported to have dispensed some $1.9 billion since 1982. A lot of its income derives from ‘cause marketing’ where The Foundation co-operates with big business on  joint ventures (as opposed to philanthropy where they just hand over donations).Pool questions whether such  partnerships are ethically and morally acceptable when they are with Companies who make products which use chemicals that are linked to cancer themselves. They include giant Cosmetic Corporations such as Avon and Estee Lauder who are eager to give their support to help the Movement even though they are reluctant to give any details about their research into how safe their products are and if in fact they contain ingredients that are contributing factor in the cause of cancer.  Pool may have pointed out these facts, but she never bullied her interviewees into any admission, and in fact she allowed the Marketing Manager of Ford to waffle on with some piffling double-talk that insinuated that cars never do any environmental damage at all.

Nancy Brinker, the CEO of Korman, and an ex US Ambassador (who was also the late Susan Korman’s sister) is a rather brittle over-manicured woman who never wavered of her justification for how/where the organisation raised their money even when it was from fast food giants KFC resulting in a deluge of angry emails from many survivors who were so offended by this inappropriate partnership
It’s not just the vast amounts of money now involved that were being questioned here, but more directly as to how they are being allocated and distributed. The film threw up two crucial points. Firstly a mere 5% is spent on prevention which was unanimously agreed by most of the interviewees as a crime.  At the other end of the scale there are over 30 different research bodies spending millions of dollars every year, but without any co-ordination at all.  Hence as one Doctor put it very succinctly, they are all overlapping and do exactly the same investigations & trials. and without a single exception are all focusing on urban white middle-aged women as if they are the only casualties of this cancer.
There were two other sections that raised my awareness.  Firstly I had no idea that milk products contain a nasty chemical called RBGH that farmers pump into cows to make them produce more, and which then gets pumped into us, making us get sick more. Inappropriately General Mills ‘Yoplait’ a major partner with Susan Korman was a big user of the chemically enhanced milk until there was highly successful write in campaign about this practice.  
But secondly, and more importantly, was listening to the many articulate woman who had dealt with their cancer, and others that are learning each day how to deal with their new Stage 4. Their attitude to the well-intentioned goodwill of a movement that is meant to benefit them was both revealing and exceptionally moving.
Towards the end of the movie, someone aptly articulated we all throw money at a ’cause’ like this simply because it makes us feel good.  It seems like we are actually doing something to help.  But are we really if the big Charities Board’s are peppered with the Heads of Industries that still make products that are probable factors in causing?  Shouldn’t we be doing more to stop this, and working towards preventing the next generation not suffering the same?  
It’s a sobering thought in the USA every 23 seconds someone is diagnosed with breast cancer and every 69 seconds , someone dies from it.
See this movie, and see where your money is going, it will may you think/rethink.

★★★★★★★★


Posted by queerguru  at  04:11


Genres: 

Follow queerguru

Search This Blog


View 5 min movie By: