fbpx
Wednesday, March 9th, 2011

Certified Copy

Much to my disbelief Certified Copy is opening in NY + LA to excellent reviews this weekend.  It’s not that I think it’s a bad movie; it’s just that I found it equally pretentious and emotionally flat, so frankly am surprised at its initial reception.
 

still1_wide-64283ffdbec8886e6865adedd73a8c604e2bf960-s900-c85Set in a small Tuscan town where James Miller, a celebrated English writer, is launching his latest philosophical tome, which attracts the attention of a highly interested (unnamed) woman who is desperate to discuss his work further.  He has a few hours to spare before he needs to catch his train, so agrees to meet with her and picks her up at her Gallery where she sells reproductions of antiques.  And then throughout the new few hours they spend together they enter into an intense dialogue on the nature of copies and originals in art, and in life too.

 
There is one part in the Café they end up in where they are mistaken by the staff to be a long-married couple, and they play along.  She with enthusiasm and he less so, and eventually cold fish that he is, seems to turn almost bitter about this charade.
 
The whole movie is just one long (pseudo?) intellectual exercise as the couple continuously try to score verbal points off each other. She, played by the delectable Juliet Binoche, is romantic and impassioned, but the lack of any emotional response of any kind, makes her efforts, and this movie fall painfully flat.  Miller incidentally is played by William Shimmel an English opera singer in his first (non-singing) acting role
 

Written and directed by Abbas Kairostami an award winning Iranian filmmaker, this is his first European movie, which may be a telling factor in why it so fails to work.  The book that is the centre of all the heated discussion proposes that copies are every bit as good as the ‘real thing’.   This movie is by no means a copy, but as a piece of art and an entertainment, it fails to be the real thing too.

 


Posted by queerguru  at  21:50


Genres: 

Follow queerguru

Search This Blog


View 5 min movie By: